MtothaJ wrote:
To run the v2 CPU's you need the 2013 bootblock. There has been plenty written on this subject - feel free to browse the forum for more info.
The E5-1650v2 has the advantage that it can be overclocked in the Z420 by using Intel XTU. You are still limited to a 130W TDP limit but the performance gains are still substantial especially when fully utilizing just 1-2 cores (as many programs do).
The E5-2650 v2 has locked multiplier so it doesnt benefit from the above, while the E5-1650 v1 - while multiplier unlocked - does not respond to any tweaking in XTU (core multiplier sliders are grayed out).
Thank you for this - considering your new info, yes, it does make sense to upgrade to E5-1650 v2 (even if comparing to E5-1650 v1 the 100 MHz higher base clock rate is not too much). And the ebay store is only asking for $30 more for this upgrade.
And regarding the 2013 bootblock, your intervention was pure telepathy - in sync with my similar finding on a web forum on tomshardware, I guote:
"-To determine if the Z420 can support the v2 CPUs, look in the F10 BIOS setup for the boot block date
=> If the Z420 has a boot block date of 12/28/2011, it supports only the v1 CPUs
=> If the Z420 has a boot block block of 03/06/2013, it supports both the v1 and v2 CPUs.
HP does not support updating the boot block. "
Such requirement couldn't be more than welcome. Because by doing the upgrade to the 1650 v2, I would have a double confirmation that the seller will definitely give me another used Z420, completely different than the one which they have sent originally (I'm not sure if they "mix and match" mobos and cpus, and prefer instead to pick up a completely different Z420 from the recycled stock. And move only the RAM around). I shall explicitly ask them to triple-check that the bios shows (a) the 2013 bootblock, (b) v2 suffix for the CPU, (c) Right memory assignemnts in the banks and the memory type.
Thanks a lot for all this great info! I'll ask them to go with 1650v2 upgd. And either replace the 1TB spinning HD with, or add on base of that, also a 256GB SSD drive. Because I have noticed that the 1TB 7200 rpm hdd (a Western Digital) was super-noisy - either because the original owner has put it thru lot of intensive use, or it came from somewhere else, or maybe this Z420 does not have too much sound proofing / rubber washers around bays and hdd screws etc.
Along with those 2 upgrades, I also have this in my list of notes to ask them about for the upcoming Monday Feb 26 2018 (this is when the returned pc arrives back to them):
- Ask to take care of the thermal paste on the cpu.
- Ask to confirm that the cpu is not an ES (Engineering Sample) - is there a way to independtly check for this myself? Considering how many units they have, they should be coming from reputable stocks/businesses.
- Ask for the mounting rails / bay for an additional 3.5'' spinning hdd (if I leave the 1TB spinning hdd and get the ssd instead, which is another +$30).
- Ask for a discount using the 5% store discount code that I have received from the 1st (semi-failed) sale.
- Ask for a front fan mount (standard hp p/n?). Not sure if they would have such thing.
- Ask for the "Front RAM duct" plastic part. Not sure if they'll be able to honor that, or if it is really important for the front dimm 1...4 banks to not overheat.
Anything else that you would consider wise to ask about?