Hi
Are you using and RAID controller card or it's Onboard.
And it seems like RAID has been corrupted due to which it's not allowing to execute the required actions.
And make sure you are using the same configuration HDD.
I am an HP employee, the opinions expressed here are my personal opinions, not of HP.
Make it easier for other people to find solutions, by marking my answer “Accept as Solution” if it solves your problem.
***Click on "Thumbs up" button to the left side of my post to acknowledge the post ***